Club Meeting 9th November 2026">Club Meeting 9th November 2026

President Ted welcomed members and today’s speaker Paul Barnett to the meeting.

Members stood in silence in memory of Past President Edwin Nuttall and Honorary Member Reg Gunston.

The president introduced Paul Barnett to talk on the subject of the Battle of Jutland. Paul began by asking members who they thought had won the battle and generally the opinion was that it was a draw with no outright victor.

The battle took place in the North Sea off Denmark’s Jutland Peninsula between Britain’s Grand Fleet under Vice-Admiral Sir John Jellicoe, and Imperial Germany’s High Seas Fleet under Vice-Admiral Reinhard Scheer. Paul described how the battle involved extensive manoeuvring and three main engagements from 31st May to 1st June 1916 and was also the largest naval battle and only full-scale clash of battleships of the war.

We were given great detail of the ships and manpower involved and also insights into the personalities of the main protagonists. Included in this was a critique of Admiral David Beatty, especially with regard to signalling failures which led to many difficulties during the action. Paul also saluted the four British personnel awarded the Victoria Cross, Jack Cornwell, Barry Bingham, Francis Harvey and William Loftus Jones.

TThe end of the battle saw the German fleet retire to safety in their home port, which despite the fact that Britain had broken the German codes and encryption key, the Grand Fleet was unable to prevent. This led to great criticism of Jellicoe.

As far as the question of who won, statistically in terms of shipping and manpower losses the Germans won, but the fact that the German High Seas Fleet never left port again and the effect this had on the German moral and war effort proved to be decisive in favour of Britain.

Following question from the floor Robert Jennings gave the vote of thanks and members showed their appreciation of a fine talk with a round of applause.